Overall Rating: 4 Stars
One of the newest additions to Downtown Disney is this craft burger locale that offers exactly what the sign says: burgers and shakes. Prices are a bit high, but the quality and quantity of food you get can be enough to forget all that. Be prepared for a big mess, though, and grab plenty of napkins!
Atmosphere: 4 Stars
You can tell when you step inside that Black Tap markets itself as a trendy (dare I say "hip") restaurant and that fits very well with its location in Downtown Disney - right in the middle of the busiest section of the district. You may have to wait in a line to order but generally there are no issues finding a seat - particularly since the staff seats you. It has all the benefits of a quick-service location and the perks of a table-service joint since you don't have to wait around to listen for your order number and lumber back with trays of food. They bring it out to your table.
Food Quality: 4 Stars
The shakes are called "crazy" for a reason because they're loaded with toppings that extend beyond the glass and coat the rim. These you probably certainly want to split with others. They are milk shakes and should not be expected to be thick, but I can't wait to have my next one!